Talk:Sword

These swords in-game?
Can anybody confirm or disconfirm that any of the following swords are in the game?: These swords are listed on several websites and in the Prima Guide, but I have never seen them in the game myself. --Tetris L 18:44, 16 Sep 2005 (EST)
 * Ascalon Razor (collector / crafter weapon?)
 * Canthan Blade
 * Canthan Machete
 * Canthan Saber
 * Canthan Shortsword
 * Crusader's Sword
 * Krytan Sword
 * Longclaw
 * Rekki Blade
 * Rinblade (collector / crafter weapon?)
 * Sephis Sword
 * Shining Gladius
 * Wyvern Blade


 * Yes, I think the Rinblade comes from crafters, never seen any of the other ones either. --Eightyfour-onesevenfive 19:05, 16 Sep 2005 (EST)


 * Confirmed. You can get a "Rinblade" from Penelope Hoode, a collector in Old Ascalon. And the "Ascalon Razor" is available from Louise Haup in Piken Sqare. --Tetris L 19:13, 16 Sep 2005 (EST)


 * This list has to go from this page. It makes no sense to say: Here is a list of all swords, and... For a list of all swords see Category:Swords. The list is either here or in the category. I would agree if you list TYPES of sword (as I thought the list would be). i.e. show a picture of a sword and then all the names of swords that look like that. I'm not very good with swords, but for Hammers, there are a few hammers that have the Ram's head, a few that have the big ball at the end... etc. I am assuming swords are the same. But, please, no dredundant lists. --Karlos 20:23, 16 Sep 2005 (EST)


 * I'd agree if the Category:Swords list was complete. But it isn't. As long as it isn't complete, the list shows us which ones are missing. --Tetris L 20:47, 16 Sep 2005 (EST)
 * On a side note, I was thinking about going even 1 step further and create a GALLERY of all the sword images. --Tetris L 20:47, 16 Sep 2005 (EST)


 * Just to bring it up again... With all the new weapons being introduced with factions, I think we should remove the lists of weapon types from their main articles. Reasons:
 * The lists will become very long over time. Just wait for chapter three...
 * There are weapons with a common name and different designs. A Canthan Sickle looks different from a Tyrian Sickle. List it two times? Once for each continent?
 * I would agree to a seperate article, something like "Sword/List of all swords", just for reference what we have documented and what not, like suggested by tetris up there, way back then. But I don't see a place for this in the article "Sword". --84-175 (talk) 15:03, 30 April 2006 (CDT)

Sword speed
it is not true that swords swing every 1.00 seconds. I tested it several times - they swing at 1.33 seconds, same speed as an axe.
 * From what I've read elsewhere (forgot where) I agree. Sward and axe have same speed, hammer slower. -PanSola 17:39, 14 February 2006 (CST)

something's getting old
Every now and then an anon comes in and edit the hammer or the axe article to say the sword swings once every second, and then I revert them.

Now, if they were doing it on the Sword article, I feel absolutely proper to add a big note saying "There is a general conception that swords swing once every 1 second, however that is not true. To discuss this issue, see Talk:Sword".

However, to add that to hammer, axe, and dagger, and whatever other weapons, seems like a bad idea to me.

Sigh, why do those anons edit every article BUT the sword article?

sorry, just ranting. -PanSola 17:12, 24 February 2006 (CST)

something's getting old
Every now and then an anon comes in and edit the hammer or the axe article to say the sword swings once every second, and then I revert them.

Now, if they were doing it on the Sword article, I feel absolutely proper to add a big note saying "There is a general conception that swords swing once every 1 second, however that is not true. To discuss this issue, see Talk:Sword".

However, to add that to hammer, axe, and dagger, and whatever other weapons, seems like a bad idea to me.

Sigh, why do those anons edit every article BUT the sword article?

sorry, just ranting. -PanSola 17:13, 24 February 2006 (CST)

(oops, to be fair, the sword article did get one anon edit that made it 1 sec). -PanSola 17:13, 24 February 2006 (CST)

External link?
Is that external link needed anymore? We have plenty of pictures of swords here on GuildWiki. --Draygo Korvan 14:05, 25 May 2006 (CDT)