Talk:Chained Soul

Exact time on rez
Hey I added the note in that they rez after dieing. Can anyone add the exact time in here? --zero rogue 02:16, January 5 2006
 * Is it a resurrect or is it another spawn? Specifically, would Frozen Soil keep it down? - 02:55, 22 June 2006 (CDT)

Ghost?
The name Chained Soul and the description implies that they are Ghosts, but they do not behave like ghosts at all: They do not have the typical translucent look of a ghost, they are fleshy and I think they even leave a corpse. IMHO the fact alone that they are fleshy justifies to take them out of the ghost category. -- 05:22, 1 February 2006 (UTC)


 * Yet, their name is an obvious indicator as to what they are. We are faced once again with ANet's inconsistency. The Chained souls are supposed to be tormented souls in the after life. They are definitely ghosts. Yet, for game considerations, they are used to produce corpses for the Dead collectors and threshers (and in the tombs to rend enchantments). Thus I believe to not categorize them as ghosts (when they clearly are ghosts) because of in-game behavior (which is clearly based on pragmatic reasons, not taxonomical reasons) is, in my opinion, wrong. It will create all kinds of silly divisions. I recommend we, fo rnow, just compile all the vital statistics of the different undead creatures and in terms of what applies to them and what doesn't then we should try and sort them out once we have enough data.
 * To add to the confusion. Smites have been "modified" in the last update. They no longer leave corpses to exploit. Still, unlike the Darknesses and Dying Nightmares, they DO leave actual corpses, you just can't exploit them. the other two just leave that dark spot on the ground that usually tells a necro that the creature is a ghost. --Karlos 06:55, 1 February 2006 (UTC)