Talk:Wintersday 2005 items

Wintersday items? --Fyren 22:17, 26 December 2005 (UTC)


 * Let's solve this dilemma quick before I create any more pages or any bigger a mess.. Will we go with the official name "Wintersday Items" and "Wintersday Update" and "Wintersday Quests" or the de facto player name "Christmas..." decision time, fast!! --Karlos 23:10, 26 December 2005 (UTC)

Who is cooter brown ++ 05:37, 27 December 2005 (UTC)

Official +
Using official names would be the more consistent approach. Yes, everybody knows what we mean when we say Christmas items, but ArenaNet has gone to the length to make it a culture-neutral (not to mention Tyrian) holiday and so should GuildWiki. Not everyone who plays GW is a Christian.
 * actually I think they went only a *tiny* length to make it culture neutral... At least everything I see is a blatant reference of Xmas, and nothing of the Jewish holiday on the same date.  Jewish people please correct me if I'm wrong.  All Anet did was a simple name substitution to try cover up the fact that it is tailored to Christian celebrations of Xmas.