Talk:Tomb of the Primeval Kings (location)

I don't agree that this is a mission. It doesn't have a mission icon, it has a PvP Arena icon. 03:36, 18 Jun 2005 (EST)

And let's get rid of these unnecessary (Location) addon's. Add (Mission) to distinguish, but let's have the same format without (Location) for ALL locations.

No, I disagree with that. If there is a mission and a location with the same name then a disambiguation is, in my opinion, necessary. If someone types in "Fort Ranik" then I think it's best to present them with the choice of the location or the mission information. You could make persuasive arguments that they are going to be more interested in the location than the mission, or that they are going to be more concerned about the mission than the location. For example, for the former argument you could say that all locations should have the same syntax, i.e. free of the word "(Location)" in their title. Equally, for the latter argument you could say that when users want information on a mission they probably won't want to type the word "(Mission)" after the url, and people won't often be that concerened about the location information. I think I would personally favor the latter case over the former, which would mean that (Location) is used, and (Mission) is not. My point is that since no one is ever going to agree over this issue the disambiguation page makes the most sense. 22:56, 18 Jun 2005 (EST)


 * Its an old discussion I see, but this point present me with lots of trouble as I try to create the PvP related articles. Seeing how there are no disambiguity pages so far, I will refrain from creating one. However I will set all redirects and links to the tournament page Tomb of the Primeval Kings (Mission), since that is what everyone will be looking for when typing "tombs". This page is redundant, since it is a copy of Tomb of the Primeval Kings --Xeeron 01:42, 24 Sep 2005 (EST)
 * Ok I got the system here now: All doubles have 2 pages, one with (Mission), one with (Location), and the redirects always lead to the mission. --Xeeron 02:45, 24 Sep 2005 (EST)