Category talk:GvG builds

Yea, don't delete. --Theonemephisto 17:21, 25 July 2006 (CDT)

Characters I think we need
 * Shock Axe W/E Shock Axe
 * Charge Sword W/E Charge Sword
 * Devastating Hammer W/any Devastating Hammer


 * Surge Mesmer (Gale and Hard Res) Me/Mo E-Surge Mesmer
 * Expel Hexes Dom Mesmer (Gale and Hard Res) Me/E Expel Dom Mesmer
 * Glyph of Renewal Dom Mesmer
 * Illusion Mesmer
 * Fast Cast Curses Mesmer Me/N FC Curse Anti-Melee


 * Flashbot air E/Mo E/Mo Flashbot Support Caster
 * Water E/Mo E/Mo Hydro Support Caster
 * Fire E/Mo ~ User:Skuld/E/Mo Burning Flag Runner E/Mo Pyro Support Caster
 * Water Flagger
 * Air Flagger
 * Air/Water Flagger with BFlash ~ User:Spawn/E/Mo Hybrid Runner


 * Boon Prot Mo/Me Boon Prot
 * WoH Monk
 * Blessed Light Monk Mo/Me Blessed Light Hybrid


 * Crip Shotter ~ R/Me Cripshot Ranger
 * Distortion Trapper
 * Melandru's Arrows Ranger

Some of these are already on the site somewhere, they just need to be moved here. --Vindexus 18:14, 25 July 2006 (CDT)
 * No need to recat, just add the appropriate categories. There is nothing inherently detrimental about an article having multiple categories. A GvG build, for instance, is by definition also a PvP build. -- [[Image:Bishop_icon2.png]] Bishop [ rap|con ] 18:37, 25 July 2006 (CDT)
 * There is something bad about putting articles in every step along a category tree. It's confusing and unhelpful.  A build in the GvG category is a PvP build because GvG builds is in the PvP builds category.  --68.142.14.19 18:47, 25 July 2006 (CDT)
 * Yea, I added the links to stuff that we already have just so I cna keep track of what we need to make. Looks like we got some work to do.

Ok, this is starting to look like the PvP build section - a bunch of builds that aren't really supposed to be there. Fury Scythe? C'mon, I know no one has seen that. Just because it looks like it might work doesn't mean it's built for GvG. The CC Migraine Mesmer is another one. Who uses CC in GvG? MoR Mes with Ether Lord and Wastrel's, Psychic Vampire, sorry never seen em. Stike Assassin...as a single character? Please, that is ridiculous. We can screw up the RA and TA build section, but can we please keep the GvG section clean from crap?--69.165.142.170 14:16, 31 July 2006 (CDT)
 * some of these are guesses on my part, i don't PvP much, but i'm a Librarian/Mesmer. feel free to change the categories if it doesn't work. --Honorable Sarah [[image:Honorable_Icon.gif]] 14:20, 31 July 2006 (CDT)
 * Better? &mdash; Skuld 14:24, 31 July 2006 (CDT)
 * Much, Thank you :)--69.165.142.170 18:13, 31 July 2006 (CDT)
 * And, if you could get rid of that crap "Holy Hammer" and "Unstoppable Hammer", it would be perfect.--69.165.142.170 21:19, 2 August 2006 (CDT)
 * those are tested and favored builds. my personal distate and your violent dislike are not sufficent to remove them. sorry --Honorable Sarah [[image:Honorable_Icon.gif]] 21:41, 2 August 2006 (CDT)
 * I wouldn't concider my dislike 'violent', but I do dislike them...and for multiple reason. First of all, you call them tested and favored. Then why do both use Heavy Blow instead of Fierce Blow? It is a widely known fact that Fierce Blow became 'favored' over Heavy Blow after the release of Factions. Also, Healing Signet is widely used over Endure Pain, and in fact, in the past couple of months, I haven't seen one top rated guild warrior using Endure. Finally, before you say the builds are 'tested', answer me why one of the builds uses For Great Justice instead of Frenzy? At 10E and 45s recharge, especially on a hammer, that skill is pathetic. "Unstoppable Hammer" is just a "Fierce Hammer" that is old, and switches out Irresistable/Bash for Plague Touch. All "Fierce Hammer" has to include is PT in variants, and you have a better "Unstoppable Hammer" thread. Sorry if I ranted on a little too much, but since IMO GvG is the highlight of Guild Wars, I think the section should be clean and noob-free.--69.165.142.170 03:27, 3 August 2006 (CDT)
 * Using a phrase like "noob-free" screams of elitism. We don't block off areas of the site like that. This is a community and not a commune for the privileged. Any article may be continually and mercilessly edited but we don't make some kind of distinction between those who are considered "noobs" and those who are not. The writing anyone submits here should always be regarded on it's own merit, not the writer's sense of self worth. If you are indeed knowledgeable in the art of GvG then start looking through some builds that interest you and improve them, the meta game constantly changes but our articles don't always follow at the same pace, you're both welcome and encouraged to improve them though. --Xasxas256 03:41, 3 August 2006 (CDT)