Talk:Stoneherder's Flatbow

Hmmm, even thought this is highly speculative, I like how it is written and I think it makes clear what is know and what is not known and why the speculation is made. --Karlos 02:23, 21 June 2006 (CDT)

Actual Stats vs Speculations
Actual stats are unknown and should be list as 'unknown'. Speculations and other guesses should come with all due warnings. --FrogDevourer

Possible Stats
max dmg req 9 +15% dmg (always) -10AL while attacking sundreing 20/20 health +30


 * I don't see -10AL whle attacking and Health +30 supported by anything. In fact, there were no -10AL while attacking modifiers for any of the other propphecies greens, be them Axes, Hammers, Swords, or Bows.  Thus I find the above speculation very doubtful. - 06:03, 21 June 2006 (CDT)


 * True, but its the only dmg mod without it being a +energy bow, which rotwing already is.  I guess I just need to farm SF more :)


 * editted*
 * True, but Seeing as though sorrows furnace doesn't drop any 15% Always bows, and the rotwing is already a +5 Energy, that maybe they would ADD a 15% Always green bow to TYRIA, as they are already available in cantha.


 * "its the only dmg mod without it being a +energy bow" <- I am so lost as to what you mean here. - 11:28, 21 June 2006 (CDT)


 * You have to think if my theory below is true, the bow obviously has a sundering mod and is a flatbow. If this green weapon was created the same time the other Sorrow Furnace greens were made and just wasn't implemented, my guess is it's either 15%^50, 15% while enchanted, or 15% while in stance (comparing other unique bows from that area). As to the second mod, I'm guessing +7 vs Physical Attacks, or +5 Defense. -Gares 06:51, 22 June 2006 (CDT)
 * I agree with Gares' theory. The second upgrade could be fortitude also. - 08:28, 22 June 2006 (CDT)
 * ur right, gares, about the dmg-mod, sundering must be, else it wouldnt appear on that list. the second mod may be everything, maybe even mark+1/20%.... HJT 06:08, 23 June 2006 (CDT)

Query
Do you think they created some simple code to retro-upgrade all unique items that had 10/10 sundering to 20/20, but still have not noticed the bow is not implemented into the mod, if it is Drago Stoneherder's third bow? I would think with all the posts about the "unknown bow", someone at ANet would have seen something since it has been a rumor for ages now. Although, there is still no proof it has not been introduced after this update to date. -Gares 07:25, 21 June 2006 (CDT)
 * Well I wrote to Anet and the GM anwsered me like I was a cry baby that bitch because nothing never drop for him or that was a big noob ( he refered me [|here]). Lazy Gm :p. Wrote them back asking if the were aware that it was most likely a bug or an error in the patch note if the bow was took out of the game.&mdash; ├ A  ratak  ┤  17:54, 27 July 2006 (CDT)
 * As much as I'd love another unique bow I think it's obvious that the "Stoneherder's Bow" that was mentioned in the update was in fact the "Drago's Flatbow" we all know and love. There was no mention of two bow's in the update and I see - assuming - that as other bosses drop 3 items it's not always true they all will.  I'm a firm beleiver that a 3rd bow drop from Drago Stoneherder does not exist in GW at this time and has not existed in the past.  However, it is possible a new one is added later.  Still, some are skeptical as to it's existance so I think it's worth leaving the link here in case it's looked for.[[Image:VallenIconwhitesmall.JPG]]  Vallen Frostweaver  11:49, 4 October 2006 (CDT)